New Jersey Supreme Court Rules 4-2 that Recall Cannot Apply to Members of Congress

On November 18, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled 4-2 that the U.S. Constitution prevents states from providing for the recall of members of Congress.  See the opinion here.  The majority decision and the dissent, together, are 142 pages.


Comments

New Jersey Supreme Court Rules 4-2 that Recall Cannot Apply to Members of Congress — 7 Comments

  1. One more item to add to the nearly dead U.S.A. Constitution.

    How many States have recall sections in their State constitutions ???

    i.e. terms of office — cut short by a recall election.

  2. Law school question: can a state court decision invalidating part of a state constitution on federal constitutional grounds be appealed to the federal courts? It doesn’t seem likely, but I thought I’d ask.

  3. Since the term of office of gerrymander U.S.A. Senators is 6 years in the Fed Const. — 17th Amdt — then there is an obvious Federal Question — in connection with the Fed Supremacy clause in Art. VI.

  4. I suspect that this is seen as adding an additional rule or qualification for this particular federal office, and the courts have generally opposed States doing that, except when it comes to ballot access.

    A [odd] distinction between ballot access rules and qualifications for federal public office was made by the court in a 1990s case involving term limits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.