Home Uncategorized Roll-Call Vote on Ryan-Murray Budget Compromise Shows Little Correlation Between Type of Primary and the Vote

Roll-Call Vote on Ryan-Murray Budget Compromise Shows Little Correlation Between Type of Primary and the Vote

On December 12, the U.S. House passed the Ryan-Budget compromise budget resolution, HJR 59. The measure passed easily, by a vote of 332-94. Seven members did not vote and there are two vacancies. Among the members of the House who voted, only 22.1% voted “No.” Some of the “no” votes were cast by Democrats who believe the bill stifles worthy spending, and some of the “no” votes were cast by Republicans who believe the bill spends too much. The media tends to support the idea that both types of opposition are “extreme”; no such opinion should be inferred from this blog post.

Among members of Congress from open primary states, 23.0% voted “No.” Among members from closed primary states, 19.6% voted “No.” Among members from semi-closed primary states, 28.9% voted “No.” Among members from top-two states, 17.4% voted “No.”

Opponents of closed primaries constantly express a belief that closed primaries yield more extreme politicians, yet in this vote, as in recent similar roll-call votes, open primaries seem more like to produce “extreme” politicians. Here is the roll-call vote.

All six of Washington state’s Democrats voted for the bill, which lowered the percentage of “no” votes from top-two states. Chances are not all of the Washington Democrats would have voted for the bill, except for the fact that U.S. Senator Patty Murray, a Democrat from Washington state, put her prestige on the line as the Democrat who negotiated the compromise, and her fellow Democrats from her home state wanted to support her.

One Response

  1. Demo Rep

    The USA H.Reps. is one giant EVIL ANTI-Democracy minority rule gerrymander system –

    1/2 votes x 1/2 gerrymander districts = 1/4 control.

    Actual minority rule – about 28-30 percent.

    Much worse primary math with the left/right special interest gangs picking the nominees – esp. in the de facto one party safe seat gerrymander areas (i.e. the EVIL hard core MONSTERS).

    ALL houses of ALL State legislatures are mini-copies of the USA H.Reps. system — due to SCOTUS.

    P.R. and nonpartisan App.V. — before it is too late.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>