On November 17, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision affirming that the Green Party had a right to block a petitioning candidate for Congress from getting on the ballot using the party’s name without its permission. In re: Nomination Papers of Andrew Tupone, 56 MAP 2026. Here is the 22-page decision.
The Court had to struggle a little bit to explain why the Green Party, which is not ballot-qualified, qualifies to veto petitioning candidates who use its name without permission. It wrote, “As demonstrated on the record before the Commonwealth Court, the Green Party of Pennsylvania has been established in Pennsylvania for twenty-five years, is a known political entity in Pennsylvania, has a structure and established platform of social justice, grassroots democracy, peace and nonviolence, and ecological wisdom; and has an endorsement and vetting process designated in its bylaws. Absent the established identity and structure, a challenge based on lack of entitlement to claim the party designation would be difficult, if not impossible, to prove.”
It would be a good idea if the legislature passed a law on the subject of how an unqualified party could reserve its party name protection rights. However, the Pennsylvania legislature, more than the legislature of any other state, has a very bad record of refusing to amend the election law after a minor party wins a lawsuit.